Fly Fishing Trip Report

Many readers expressed interest in my fly fishing trip with my friend and research partner, Roger Crandell, and asked for details. Here, then, is my first-ever fly fishing trip report.

We began in Lake City, Colorado, the only incorporated municipality in Hinsdale County. It’s the least densely populated county in Colorado, with just 843 residents as of the 2010 census. Tall mountains abound, including several fourteeners. There are few roads. It’s one of the most remote counties in the United States.

We stayed at G&M Cabins, which were great. The woman at the front desk was friendly and helpful, and offered us an upgrade to a two-bedroom cabin for a minor extra charge. The cabin was recently refurbished with modern amenities, but still retains its charm. We could park Roger’s 1999 Toyota 4Runner, with its classic off-road rugged shape he and I both love, which they don’t make anymore, right next to the cabin. We enjoyed a screened porch, sitting area, clean kitchen and bathroom, and separate bedrooms.

We splurged on a gourmet dinner at the only fancy restaurant in town, called Climb. The owner and chef is a perky woman who knows what she’s doing in a kitchen. The wine list is good. The food is delicious. They ran out of seared ahi tuna when Roger tried ordering it the night we arrived. We asked if she would hold a couple of them for the next night, and she did. They were good, and the pork chop I had the first night was excellent.

To add a finishing touch to our gentlemen’s journey, I picked up some whiskey, tequila, margarita mix, cheese, and crackers. Roger found a half-gallon of expired milk for free, figuring it would stay good for the duration of our trip, and some cereal. You can tell who’s the healthier between us: me. Everybody knows whiskey is more nutritious than milk.

After a 7 am breakfast with colorful locals, we went to The Sportsman Outdoors & Fly Shop, where we met our guide for the day, Peter Breeden. I don’t know what good fortune arranged for my first guiding experience to happen with Peter, but I’ll remain forever grateful. Even with nothing to compare him to, I sensed immediately that he knew what he was doing. More important, I liked his manner, the way he explained parts of the art that are second-nature to him by now but were unknown to me. He never became impatient with me, never sighed with exasperation.

We spent that first day on the Lake Fork of the Gunnison River, using nymph rigs the whole day. Nymphs are flies that sink underwater, but not lures because they dangle rather than twirl through the water. Weights help them stay down and an indicator — never a bobber to fly fishermen — on top of the water to help signal when a fish strikes or nibbles. Peter could detect one far more often than I could, suddenly yelling “Set!” at which time I was supposed to jerk my rod in the downstream direction to set the hook in the fish’s mouth. You set in the downstream direction because the fish usually faces upstream.

I wasn’t thrilled with this prospect of setting the hook. I’m not fond of hunting or fishing on the face of it because I don’t like killing animals. However, we were catching and releasing, and using barbless hooks, and everybody assured me that no fish would be harmed on our trip. Sure enough, after witnessing many catches and releases of happy fish back into the current, I relaxed on this front.

The first fish I caught was a 14-inch brown trout. Peter yelled “Set!” and it worked. He yelled “You got him!” and began charging into the water while pulling his net from behind his backpack. I kept tension on the rod by making sure it never came unbent at the tip. When the fish ran, I put him on the reel, letting the drag keep tension while releasing more line to prevent exceeding the test pressure. When I finally got him close enough to Peter, I pulled his head up so Peter could scoop him from the tail end. Then, I made sure my hands were wet to avoid removing his protective mucus coating, and held him up while taking one knee for a photo.

I have several such photos, the hallmarks being a 19-inch cutbow and a 20-inch rainbow trout. That last one was a trophy fish, according to Peter. She was beautiful, too, with complex spotting and mesmerizing hues of color through her scales. I held her gently for the photo, then lowered her into the water, where she waited a moment in my hands, then wiggled forward into still water where she seemed to get her bearings, then off she dashed into the current as if nothing had happened.

Roger and I caught twenty fish that day, which both he and Peter said was a very good day. Peter remarked we worked hard for them, too, continuing to wade upstream to another hole when most of his clients would have taken a rest. It never felt like work to me.

Peter is on the water 300 days per year. He can tie on a new fly faster than I can select one from a box. I practiced my knots with parachute cord before the trip. I don’t advise this. Fishing line is not parachute cord. It’s best to practice with the real thing. With slender fly line, it’s like tying knots in hair, and takes practice. Peter makes it look easy. It’s not. If you’re going to give this pastime a try, be sure to practice your knots with real fishing line and real flies.

Peter is 26 years old. He began fishing when he was 6. His only break from the pastime was a stint in the Marine Corps, which instilled in him a respectful courtesy that comes through on the river. He wouldn’t say, “Come up here.” He’d say, “Step this way, please.” When I verified one of his instructions, such as to cast to a point above a rock by asking, “That rock?” he’d reply, “Yes, sir.” This crisp precision made the day easy to follow and pleasant.

If you want a memorable, worth-every-penny fly fishing trip, I recommend the waters around Lake City with Peter Breeden as your guide. It’s some of the best fishing in North America, according to people who know better than I do, and Peter is as good as guides come.

On our second day, Roger and I headed up to Big Blue Creek in the Uncompahgre Wilderness. It’s neither big nor blue, but its valley in the San Juan Mountains is stunningly gorgeous, with pointy spruce forests as far as you can see, the winding creek through willows and bushes, and cliff faces rising to the sky. We saw nobody else the whole day. We drove deep in, parked, geared up, and hiked the rest of the way to where we’d fish.

Roger took it seriously; I didn’t. I admit it. I wasn’t motivated by the tiny brook trout, and just enjoyed walking upstream in the wild setting. I cast a few times and got a few bites, but didn’t catch anything and didn’t care. Roger did better, but even he never exceeded an 8-inch fish.

Instead of snapping up fish, I snapped photos and stood looking into the sunshine for long stretches. The cool water ran around my feet in Chacos instead of river boots like I’d worn the day before. The air tasted pure. The sky was a dark blue and the clouds vivid white, and the trees so cleanly green I almost couldn’t believe they were natural. In fact, they were real nature, not the thinned-out variety that passes for it in city parks and smoggy outskirts of towns where most school field trips take place. It was the wild that bewitched Thoreau and friends, and it’s still there. Days don’t get better than that one.

From that charmed valley, we drove out to Buena Vista for our third day of fishing. You might assume, like I did, that the town’s name is pronounced with Spanish convention, but it’s not. The locals call it “Byoona” Vista and told us that the quickest way to detect a tourist is to hear them say the town’s name with Spanish pronunciation.

Our cabin was more rustic, a little too much if Roger’s grumbling about the “shower in the dungeon” was any indication. It squeaked relentlessly, making my wee-hour trips to the toilet an exercise in mine-field avoidance to prevent waking Roger. He said he never heard a thing, though, so it paid off — or he’s a sound sleeper.

Our good meals in Buena Vista were breakfasts at a cafe called Evergreen and a locally owned family restaurant called Jan’s, and a dinner at Lariat, a live-entertainment bar in a historic building downtown. Their wine list was even better than Climb’s, which is a hat tip to Lariat rather than a demerit for Climb. A glass of J. Lohr merlot after a day in the wilderness is a moment to pause and give thanks for.

What did not go well in Buena Vista was the fishing. We signed up for a float trip on the stretch of the Arkansas River below town. When I heard “float trip,” I pictured a gentle drift down calm waters with flies and line and the boat all proceeding at roughly the same leisurely pace. When our guide rolled up with a whitewater raft in tow, I knew something was amiss. It wasn’t just the boat, either. The fishing guide reminded me of all the rafters I used to know in Northern California, which is fine when you’re rafting but not so great when you’re fishing.

Down to the put-in at a rafting company’s property we went. Roger took the stern, I was on the bow, and the rapids began immediately. How in the world anybody can fly fish in whitewater rapids is beyond me and was beyond Roger, too. The guide would say “Cast onto that seam!” and we’d do so, only to have the boat turn or the oars get onto our lines, at which point the guide would yell, “You’re under the boat!” or “Keep away from the oars!” or just “Recast! Recast!”

Worse, he had us on nymphs again. What do nymphs do? Sink. What’s beneath whitewater rapids? Rocks, lots of ‘em. It was snag city for Roger and me, and there’s no hope of getting your flies back when the boat is flying past the point of your snag. We lost more rigs on that trip than Roger’s lost in the past couple of years, and then, to top it off, the guide said at about 4 pm, “Jesus. We should be taking out by now but we still have tons of river to cover.” I asked what had been holding us back. “Too many tangles and snags,” he said, and I could feel the air around Roger heat up. When he lost his next rig and the guide asked, “Do I need to pull over and re-rig you?” Roger replied tartly, “Nope. I’ve got it.” The guide never touched Roger’s rod after that.

As if that weren’t enough, Roger was nearly shot by a paintball marksman.

We were floating past a trailer park (How fitting is that?) on a rare calm stretch of water when he felt a disturbance in the air, like a hummingbird near his ear or something. He looked down to find a burst of bright orange paint and the remains of its ball shell on his grab bar. The guide reacted in a way befitting his personality, with vows of aggressive follow-up later and unnecessary explanations of why shooting paintballs at people on rafts is inadvisable. Why, it could result in eye damage. No kidding.

By the time we reached take-out, everybody was exhausted with no notable catches to report. Our only payback for hard time on the water was gear lost, lewd jokes from the guide, relief that both of Roger’s eyes were unharmed by paintballs, and gratitude that the day was over. We considered sending a statement by lowballing the tip, but ultimately decided against it. We’ll just not repeat that part of the river in that manner with that guide, but there was little purpose in causing ripples of unhappiness on our way out the door. We parted with handshakes and well wishes.

By the time Roger and I sat together at Lariat eating dinner and listening to live music, and determining that the owner was Canadian, we could laugh at the day. He told funny stories of combat casting between oars, rocks, and low-hanging trees from a spinning raft. I pointed out that the few fish I managed to catch came from the very parts of the river our guide warned us to avoid because “fish don’t go there.” One thing we could say about the day: We wouldn’t forget it.

At the end of the trip, during our drive from the reverie of rivers and mountains and fish that rise, Roger asked me if I loved fly fishing or hated it. He’d predicted before we went that I’d end up in one of those two camps. “Actually, neither,” I said. I don’t love it as much as he does, but I certainly don’t hate it. I enjoyed all three days in very different ways. By fishing score alone, the day with Peter was hands-down the best, but I discovered that a fishing trip isn’t only about fish. It’s about time with people you want to spend such quality time with. Even the not-so-good ones bring something to it, just as they do in daily life. The wilderness brings even more to it. I loved our fishing trip even though I can’t say I love fishing.

I’ll get better at it, though. I’m going to speed up my knots, work on my cast, get the gear I learned I need and stash the stuff I don’t. I like to keep it lean, very lean, with most of what I need fitting in shirt pockets and a small hip pack, and I prefer river sandals to heavy boots and waders. It’s not about what looks cool or fits some vague notion of magazine standards. It’s about personal preference, and this first trip helped me find mine.

I also learned that nothing has spread more misinformation about fly fishing than the film “A River Runs Through It.” Fish do not start biting early in the morning. They start at about 10 am. Paul’s so-called “shadow casting” technique as shown in the film is beautiful to watch, with all the line furling and unfurling in the sunshine, molecules of water refracting the light, but it doesn’t catch fish. Why? Simple. The odds of catching fish improve when your fly is in the water, not spinning through the air. The point of casting is not to deliver a Cirque du Soleil performance. It’s to present the fly to fish as naturally as possible, and they’re under water.

As for dry-fly purists, Peter put it best: They often purely catch nothing. On some days, like ours on the Lake Fork of the Gunnison, fish aren’t feeding on the surface. If a fisherman is unwilling to switch to something that gets down to where they are on such days, he won’t catch fish.

I would like to thank Roger for arranging the details of our trip, and assure him that I don’t hold our whitewater fishing day against him. He seemed to think it was his fault for selecting that float, but I never saw it that way. The company sold the trip as a float fishing trip, not a whitewater fishing trip, and it wasn’t Roger’s fault for taking them at their word.

If you want to follow in our footsteps on a fly fishing adventure of your own, I suggest you plan well in advance for a stay in Lake City with Peter as your guide. You know it’s in a guy’s blood when you ask him what he does for fun when he’s not guiding fishing trips, and he replies, “Go fishing.” He guides winters in Broken Bow, Oklahoma and summers in Lake City. He’s booked months and sometimes years in advance, so plan ahead. It’ll be worth the effort and the cost.

This entry was posted in Personal News. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.


  1. Gene Noonan
    Posted September 4, 2017 at 9:57 am | Permalink

    Nice to hear from you Jason. How ironic I’m sitting in Almont CO next to the Taylor River. I would suggest 3Rivers Resort here on the famous Taylor for your next fishing trip. We’re here elk hunting at Taylor Park up the river canyon. The mountains are miserably beautiful as my wife puts it! Best-
    Gene Noonan

    • Posted September 29, 2017 at 10:46 am | Permalink

      It sounds like you had a good trip, Gene!

  2. Daniel Reed
    Posted September 3, 2017 at 6:46 am | Permalink

    Thank you for sharing your trip with us. I enjoyed reading it. You have a flair for writing, bringing your uncanny insight to your words. Same as you do with the Kelly letter. Glad Roger is ok and wish you both continued rest and relaxation.

    • Posted September 3, 2017 at 10:36 pm | Permalink

      You’re most welcome, Daniel, and thank YOU for the kind words. I’m glad Roger is OK, too!

  • The Kelly Letter logo

    Included with Your Subscription:

Bestselling Financial Author