Are Smart Beta Funds Worth The Higher Cost?

In this video, I’ll explore whether smart-beta funds are worth their higher cost.

Smart-beta funds have become popular. They try to replicate various investing techniques, such as value and growth, with an automated formula.

Here’s how the funds were explained in a March 18, 2017 Buttonwood column in The Economist:

[Excerpt shown at 0:35.]

While it may be true that smart-beta funds are cheaper than active fund managers, it’s important to remember that active fund managers aren’t worth much. Most of them lose to plain Jane indexes.

So, we have to see whether smart-beta funds are worth their higher cost compared with standard index funds.

We’ll use the Russell 1000 index, which consists of the largest 1,000 companies from the Russell 3000 total US stock market index. It’s like the S&P 500, but with 1000 companies instead.

The index is available in its plain form from iShares with symbol IWB. Its smart-beta growth version uses symbol IWD, and value uses IWF. Here are their expenses:

[Chart shown at 2:51.]

The plain Jane index fund, IWB, charges a net expense ratio of just 0.15%, while value (IWD) and growth (IWF) charge 0.20%. Smart-beta is 33.3% more expensive.

Has it been worth it? Let’s have a look.

[Charts shown at 3:40.]

Sometimes value wins, sometimes growth wins, but you can’t know which in advance, so own the whole index.

Which have investors chosen? Value and growth, of course. AUM: IWB $18B, IWD $36B, IWF $34B.


Want more videos like this? Subscribe to The Kelly Letter YouTube channel.

Thank you for watching!

This entry was posted in Video. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.
  • The Kelly Letter
    A Complete Investment Management System
    The Kelly Letter  every Sunday morning by email.
    Like no other. Many subscribers say this is the best read of their week, astonishing in its ability to distill seven days of noise into one succinct overview of the very few items that might matter. Start your Sundays right!
    A one-page Quick Start Guide
    with page number references to full information in The 3% Signal. You'll receive access to this right away so you can begin transforming your portfolio into a performance machine immediately.
    The 3Sig Calculator.
    A thing of beauty! You'll use it to generate your own personal signals every quarter including exact share amounts to buy and sell based on your account balances. It emails you the results to make later quarters easy by keeping last quarter's numbers at your fingertips. Some subscribers say this tool alone justifies their subscription price.
    The subscriber-only section of this website
    where likeminded investors are commenting on notes and discussing in forums. Jason joins these interactions every day. They're a treasure trove of investing tips and wisdom.
    The archive of Kelly Letter notes.
    It’s a research center, searchable and smartly tagged to make gathering time-stamped material on covered subjects easy.
    The subscriber podcast.
    Jason reads every letter word-for-word. This feature was requested by subscribers who prefer audio learning. They listen on their Monday morning commute, during a workout, or while reading along at their computer.



    $200/year
    Save 17%



    $20/month
    Pay as you go
    Or sign up to receive free email and learn more about the system.
    Do you have a question?
Bestselling Financial Author